Open-when letters: how to make them and what to write
A bundle of sealed letters for life's moments. Here are 30 open-when prompts, how to fold your own envelopes, and how to package and keep the set.
Quick answer
Open-when letters are a set of sealed envelopes, each labeled for a moment ("Open when you miss me," "Open when you can't sleep") with a letter inside written for exactly that moment. Choose 8 to 15 prompts, write the letters by hand, fold each into an envelope you make from an 8½-inch paper square, label and seal it, and present the set in a small box. Budget an evening for making and a few evenings for writing.
- Time 1 – 2 hours of crafting, plus 2 – 4 hours of writing
- Difficulty Easy
- Cost $5 – $20 for paper, envelopes and a box
- Makes One set of 8 – 15 letters
Open-when letters work because they arrive at the right time. A card is read once on Valentine's Day; a letter labeled "Open when you've had a terrible day" gets opened on a terrible day, months later, when it matters most. They're a natural Valentine's gift for long-distance couples, a partner who travels, a student leaving for college or a friend going through a hard year. The craft is simple. The writing is the gift.
What you'll need
- Writing paper or stationery, letter size, for the letters
- Patterned or colored paper for envelopes: letter-size sheets trimmed to 8½ × 8½ inches, or 12 × 12 inch scrapbook paper
- Or ready-made envelopes, if you'd rather skip folding (A2 envelopes fit a letter-size sheet folded in quarters)
- A pen you like writing with; a fine-tip permanent marker for labels
- A glue stick or double-sided tape, a metal ruler, a bone folder or the back of a spoon
- Stickers, washi tape or wax seals to close the envelopes
- A small box, tin or ribbon to hold the set; optional: tissue paper, an index card for instructions
Open-when prompts
Pick the ones that fit your relationship and skip any that feel forced. Eight thoughtful letters beat thirty filler ones.
Hard days
- Open when you've had a bad day
- Open when you can't sleep
- Open when you're stressed about work or exams
- Open when you're sick
- Open when you feel like giving up
- Open when you doubt yourself
- Open when we've had a fight
Missing each other
- Open when you miss me
- Open when you need a hug
- Open when you want to hear my voice (include a QR code to a voice memo)
- Open when you're lonely
- Open when you're counting down to our next visit
Good days
- Open when you need a laugh
- Open when you've had a win
- Open when you're happy and want to share it
- Open when it's raining and you're stuck inside
- Open when you're bored
- Open when you need a date idea
Milestones and dates
- Open on Valentine's Day
- Open on your birthday
- Open on our anniversary
- Open on the first snow of the year
- Open on New Year's Eve
- Open when you start something new
- Open when you've moved into a new place
Just us
- Open when you want to know why I love you
- Open when you want to remember how we met
- Open when you need to know what I see in our future
- Open when you want to feel close to me
Need help with the words? Our guide to card messages has phrasing you can adapt, and a memory jar is a good companion project if you have more memories than envelopes.
How to make open-when letters
Choose your prompts and make a list
Write 8 to 15 prompts on a scrap sheet. Balance comforting, fun and sentimental ones so the set doesn't feel heavy. Number them so you can track which are written.
Write the letters
Handwrite each letter on one side of a letter-size sheet, or less. Speak to the moment on the label: for "Open when you can't sleep," write something calm and slow; for "Open when you need a laugh," tell a story only the two of you know. Add a small extra where it fits, such as a photo, a tea bag, a pressed flower or a printed playlist code. Keep enclosures flat.
Fold the letters
Fold each letter in half and then in half again, to about 4¼ × 5½ inches. Crease with a bone folder or the back of a spoon so it lies flat.
Cut squares for the envelopes
Trim letter-size paper to an 8½-inch square by folding one corner down to the opposite edge and cutting off the extra strip. Patterned paper looks best; lighter paper (not heavy cardstock) folds more neatly.
Fold the envelope
Lay the square patterned-side down, turned like a diamond. Center the folded letter on it, with its long side running left to right. Fold the left and right points over the letter and crease along its edges, then fold the bottom point up and crease. Remove the letter, glue the side flaps to the bottom flap where they overlap, and let it dry. Test the size with scrap paper first; the fit is snug by design.
Label each envelope
Write "Open when…" on the front in your neatest hand or with letter stickers. Number the envelopes too, if you want a reading order for some of them.
Insert and seal
Slide each letter in, fold the top flap down and seal with a sticker, washi tape or a wax seal. If you use traditional sealing wax with a flame, work over a heat-proof surface, keep the flame away from the paper, and let the seal cool before stacking. Glue-gun wax sticks are an easier, flame-free option, though the gun nozzle and wax are still hot.
Package the set
Stand the envelopes upright in a small box like files, tie them in a bundle with ribbon, or clip them to a string. Add an instruction card: "One envelope per moment. No peeking."
Tip: Write the hardest letters first, the ones for fights, illness or doubt, while you have the most energy. They're the letters that will mean the most, and the easy ones go quickly afterward.
Packaging and sending
A shoebox-sized or smaller gift box covered in plain kraft paper, with a hand-lettered "Open when…" on the lid, looks finished and keeps envelopes from bending. A tin or a wooden recipe box works too. For wrapping ideas, see how to wrap a box neatly.
If you're mailing the set to a long-distance partner, send all the envelopes together in a box or padded mailer rather than posting them one by one. Under U.S. Postal Service rules, a letter is nonmachinable (and pays an extra surcharge) if it is square or near-square, with a length-to-height ratio under 1.3, if it is too rigid, has clasps or similar closures, or has items that make its thickness uneven. A homemade envelope around 4¼ × 5½ inches sits just below that ratio, and a raised wax seal or tea bag adds bulk, so check the price at the post office if you do mail one individually.
Variations
- Digital open-when: scheduled emails or a shared folder of short videos for a partner abroad. Physical letters still feel more special.
- Open-when for a friend or child leaving home: "Open when you're homesick," "Open when you need a recipe from home."
- Open-when calendar: date the envelopes instead, one per month for a year.
- Add small treats: a packet of cocoa, a face mask or a lottery ticket inside the matching envelope. Avoid anything that could melt or leak.
Keeping the letters for years
Many people keep open-when letters long after they're opened. A few habits help paper last: the Library of Congress recommends storing paper documents flat in acid- and lignin-free folders or boxes, somewhere cool, relatively dry and stable, out of direct light, and away from attics, basements, radiators and vents. The gift box you presented them in can do the job if it's a sturdy archival one; otherwise move the letters to one once the set has been opened.
Frequently asked questions
How many open-when letters should I write?
Eight to fifteen is a comfortable range: enough to cover different moods, few enough that every letter is thoughtful. Some people make 20 or more for a long separation.
What do you write in an open-when letter?
Write directly to the moment on the envelope. Comfort for hard days, a shared memory for missing each other, a joke for boredom, and specific reasons you love them for the sentimental ones. A few short paragraphs is plenty.
Can I use store-bought envelopes?
Yes. A2 envelopes fit a letter-size sheet folded in quarters, and kraft or colored envelopes look good with hand lettering. Homemade envelopes simply let you use patterned paper.
Are open-when letters only for couples?
No. They're a lovely gift for a best friend, a child going to college, a grandparent or anyone facing a hard stretch. Just adjust the prompts.
Looking for more handmade Valentine ideas? Browse our DIY Valentine's projects, including handmade Valentine cards.
Sources
- USPS — Domestic Mail Manual 101, Physical Standards (nonmachinable letter criteria, section 1.2). pe.usps.com
- Library of Congress — How do I preserve my letters or paper documents? ask.loc.gov
Image credits. Top image: Unbroken wax seal folded letter by Unknown, CC0 1.0, via Rawpixel
Spotted something out of date or a gift that's no longer available? Tell our editors — we review every correction.