DIY gifts for your best friend, starting with open-when letters
Handmade gifts that only a best friend could make: a set of open-when letters, plus scrapbooks, scrubs and small keepsakes that mail well.
Quick answer
The most meaningful DIY gift for a best friend is a set of "open when" letters: sealed envelopes for specific moments ("open when you miss me," "open when you need a laugh"), each with a note, a photo or a tiny treat inside. It costs under $20, works across any distance, and draws on the one thing nobody else can give them: your shared history. Add a small handmade extra like sugar scrub or polymer clay earrings if you want something to unwrap.
- Time 2 – 3 hours, best spread over a few evenings
- Difficulty Easy
- Cost About $10 – $20
- Makes A set of 8 – 12 letters in a box or bundle
Best friends already know your taste, your jokes and the stories nobody else remembers. A handmade gift works when it uses that knowledge. Generic crafts can feel like a cheaper version of a store gift; a personal one feels like something only you could have made.
Project: "open when" letters
- 8 – 12 envelopes (mix colors or sizes for a nicer stack)
- Good writing paper or cardstock, and a pen you like writing with
- Printed photos of the two of you (instant-camera or 4 x 6 prints)
- Small flat extras: tea bags, a face mask sheet, a playlist code, stickers, a pressed flower, a coffee gift card
- Washi tape, stickers or a wax seal kit to close the envelopes
- A box, tin or ribbon to keep the set together
Choose the moments
Pick 8 to 12 situations that fit your friend's life right now: "open when you had a bad day," "open when you can't sleep," "open on your birthday," "open when you need to remember how great you are," "open when you just got good news." If they are starting a new job or moving away, include moments tied to that.
Draft before you write
Jot down notes for each letter on scrap paper first: a memory you share, something you admire about them, an inside joke. Specifics make it feel like you, not a greeting card.
Write each letter
Half a page to a page is plenty. A good structure is a memory, why it matters to you, and something to do right now ("Go make that terrible microwave popcorn we used to eat and call me").
Add a small extra
Match each envelope to its moment: a tea bag for "can't sleep," a photo for "miss me," a funny printed meme for "need a laugh." Keep extras flat and light if you plan to mail the set.
Label and seal
Write the "open when…" line clearly on the front. Seal with washi tape, a sticker or wax. If you use a wax seal kit with a flame or melting spoon, work on a heat-safe surface and keep it away from paper you are not sealing.
Package the set
Stack the envelopes in a decorated shoebox or a tin, or tie them with ribbon. Add a top note with one rule: only open each one when the moment really happens.
Tip: Include one "open now" envelope on top. It gives your friend something to read the moment they get the gift, which makes the handover more fun.
More DIY gifts for a best friend
A friendship scrapbook
Collect photos, ticket stubs and screenshots from your years together and arrange them by year or by trip. Our scrapbook album tutorial covers layout and binding. It takes longer than the letters but becomes a treasured keepsake.
Homemade sugar scrub
A jar of scrub in your friend's favorite scent, with a handwritten label, is quick, inexpensive and actually used. See how to make sugar scrub for oils, storage and a note on using it up within a reasonable time.
Polymer clay earrings or a keychain
Matching earrings, or a keychain shaped like an inside joke, are a fun weekend project. Bake polymer clay exactly as the brand's package directs, use tools you do not use for food, and ventilate the room. Our polymer clay earrings guide walks through it.
A custom playlist with a handmade cover
Build a playlist of songs tied to your friendship, then make a "cover" card with a scannable code and a short liner note for each track.
A "reasons you're my best friend" jar
Fill a jar with rolled notes, each with one reason, memory or compliment. It uses the same idea as the letters but in a format they can dip into any time.
Choosing the right one
- Long-distance friend: open-when letters or a jar of notes, since both mail well. More ideas are in long-distance best friend gifts.
- The sentimental one: a scrapbook or letters.
- The practical one: sugar scrub or a useful keychain, with a short note.
- The one who laughs at everything: lean on inside jokes, or pair a handmade card with a small funny gift.
Giving it well
Handmade gifts are best given in person if you can, so you can watch them read the first letter or open the box. If you are mailing it, use a sturdy box, pad loose items, and send a message the day it arrives. There is no need to apologize for a gift being homemade; with a best friend, that is usually what makes it special.
Frequently asked questions
What can I make for my best friend's birthday?
Open-when letters with an "open on your birthday" envelope on top, a reasons jar with one note for each year you have been friends, or a scrapbook of the past year.
What is a cheap but meaningful DIY gift for a best friend?
A jar of handwritten notes or a set of letters. Both cost a few dollars in paper and envelopes; the value is in what you write.
How many "open when" letters should I write?
Eight to twelve is a good set. It feels generous without being so many that the writing becomes repetitive.
What if I'm not crafty?
Choose letters or a notes jar. They need no special skills, only time and honesty. Neat handwriting matters less than specific memories.
For more keepsake ideas, browse friendship keepsake gifts or our full collection of DIY gifts for loved ones.
Image credits. Top image: Sealing wax on letters by Simon A. Eugster, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Spotted something out of date or a gift that's no longer available? Tell our editors — we review every correction.