Skip to content

Independent gift guides · researched by real people · updated every season

Etiquette Rules

Regifting etiquette: when it's OK and when it isn't

Regifting can be thoughtful when the item is new, suits the new recipient and leaves the original giver's circle. Here is how to judge it and do it well.

Regifting etiquette: when it's OK and when it isn't

Quick answer

Regifting is generally fine when the item is new and complete, genuinely suits the new recipient, and travels outside the original giver's circle. Skip it for handmade, personalized or heirloom gifts, anything used or opened, and food past its best. Remove every trace of the first giver, rewrap it fresh, and never invent a story about where it came from.

  • Usually OK New, unopened, generic items: candles, plain scarves, kitchen tools, books
  • Avoid Handmade, monogrammed, heirloom, used or opened items
  • Golden rule The new recipient would choose it for themselves

Is regifting rude?

Attitudes have softened. Etiquette writers once treated regifting as slightly sneaky; today most see it as practical, even thoughtful, as long as the gift is chosen for the new person rather than simply passed along to clear a shelf. The Week's 2022 roundup of etiquette advice quotes one columnist arguing that regifting shouldn't be a "dirty festive secret."

What makes a regift polite or rude is the same thing that makes any gift polite or rude: whether it fits the person receiving it. A brand-new board game handed to a friend who loves strategy games is a good gift, whatever its history. A dusty candle passed on to the next name on your list is not.

When regifting works

Run any candidate through four quick checks.

  1. Is it new and complete? Original packaging, all parts, instructions intact. Guidance reported by WTOP names "brand new" with the box and instructions as a basic condition.
  2. Would this person pick it themselves? If you have to talk yourself into it, it's not the right match.
  3. Is it generic rather than personal? Town and Country, cited by The Week, suggests items like a beautiful candle or a plain scarf. Practical household items are also a safe category.
  4. Is the new recipient outside the giver's circle? Giving the item to someone who knows the original giver is the classic way a regift gets discovered.

What never to regift

  • Handmade or very thoughtfully chosen gifts. Someone put themselves into that object.
  • Monogrammed or personalized items, and anything with a hidden inscription or note.
  • Family heirlooms; they belong in the family or back with the person who gave them.
  • Used or worn items presented as new. If something is gently used, say so, or donate it instead.
  • Opened or expired food, opened beauty products and underwear.
  • Partly used gift cards. If you pass on a full gift card, check its fees and expiry date first.
  • Anything back to the original giver, unless it's a long-running family joke.

How to regift gracefully

  • Inspect the item closely: check inside the box, between book pages and under the lid for cards, tags or notes.
  • Remove price stickers and old gift tags, and replace the wrapping entirely. See our gift wrapping guides for a fresh finish.
  • Make sure the box isn't crushed, faded or dusty. If it is, rehouse the item or don't regift it.
  • Keep a simple note of what came from whom, so you never offer something back to the person who gave it.
  • Add something personal: a handwritten card or a small extra that ties the gift to the recipient.

Tip: If you're asked directly where a gift came from, be honest. A light "It was given to me, and the moment I saw it I thought of you" is far easier to live with than an invented shopping trip that unravels later.

Where regifting is expected

Some settings practically invite it. White elephant and swap parties often welcome regifts, and many families now openly agree to pass things along to cut cost and waste. NBC News, in a 2019 piece on avoiding unwanted gifts, notes that some people even ask for regifted or secondhand items for exactly those reasons.

In those settings, honesty is the whole point, so there's nothing to hide. Outside them, the checks above still apply.

If you receive a regift

Say thank you and leave it there. Etiquette expert Myka Meier, quoted by The Week, advises staying quiet when you suspect a regift. Pointing it out only embarrasses the giver, and the gesture of thinking of you is the same either way.

Better options than a poor regift

If an item fails the checks, you still have choices. You can exchange it at the store (a gift receipt makes this easy), donate it to a charity shop, or offer it to a friend who has mentioned wanting exactly that thing, framed honestly as "I have one I won't use; would you like it?" That's not a gift at all, just generosity, and it carries no etiquette risk.

If you'd rather stop the flow of unwanted things altogether, our guide on how to decline a gift politely covers how to ask for fewer gifts before the next holiday.

Frequently asked questions

How long should I wait before regifting?

There's no set rule, but passing something on immediately to someone in the same circle raises the odds of being found out. The bigger question is whether it suits the new person.

Should I tell the recipient it's a regift?

You don't have to volunteer it for a new, suitable item. If asked, tell the truth. For anything used, always say so.

Can I regift something I received at work?

Yes, if it's generic and you give it outside the office. Regifting a client or company gift to a coworker who saw you receive it is a quick way to cause awkwardness.

Is regifting a gift card OK?

An unused card can be a fine regift. Check the balance, expiry date and any fees first, and never pass on a partly used card as a gift.

For the rest of our gifting guidelines, visit etiquette rules.

Sources

  1. The Week — Regifting presents: what are the rules? (2022). theweek.com
  2. WTOP — When is it acceptable to regift? (2013). wtop.com
  3. NBC News — How to (politely) avoid getting unwanted gifts (2019). nbcnews.com

Image credits. Top image: Christmas wrap by Iwona Erskine-Kellie, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Written by

Gift specialist and lead author at GiftLoving. Jimmy has worked in the gift business for more than 13 years, makes handmade gifts himself, and writes about what makes a present feel thoughtful to the person who receives it.