Skip to content

Independent gift guides · researched by real people · updated every season

Under $10

Non-candy Halloween treats for trick-or-treaters and classrooms

Cheap, allergy-friendly Halloween treats for trick-or-treaters and classroom parties, with per-child costs, how the Teal Pumpkin Project works and the safety rules for toddlers.

We independently research every pick. If you buy through our links we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Non-candy Halloween treats for trick-or-treaters and classrooms

Quick answer

The best non-candy Halloween treats are cheap, light and fun on their own: stickers, temporary tattoos, pencils, glow bracelets, mini notebooks, bubbles and spider rings. Bought in bulk, most cost 10 to 50 cents per child. Put them in a separate bowl from any candy, display a teal pumpkin so families with food allergies know you have them, and keep small toys and glow sticks for older kids only.

  • Typical cost 10¢ – 50¢ per trick-or-treater; $1 – $3 per classroom favor
  • Signal A teal pumpkin by the door (Teal Pumpkin Project)
  • Under-3s No small parts, small balls or glow sticks
  • Check Latex-free items; some moldable clays contain wheat

Non-candy Halloween treats let every child leave your door with something, including kids with food allergies, diabetes, braces or family limits on sugar. They also suit classroom parties, where many schools discourage food. Below are the best Halloween treats for kids that are not food, grouped by budget, plus the safety rules worth knowing. For this year's date and a countdown, see our Halloween calendar page.

What is the Teal Pumpkin Project?

The Teal Pumpkin Project is a Halloween campaign run by Food Allergy Research & Education (FARE), a US nonprofit. It began with a Tennessee family whose son has a severe food allergy and who put a teal-painted pumpkin outside to show they offered non-food treats; FARE took it national in 2014. Taking part is simple: offer non-food treats in a separate bowl, put a teal pumpkin or FARE's free printable sign by your door, and, if you like, add your home to FARE's online map so families can plan a route. You can still hand out candy as well.

FARE notes that about one in 13 children in the US has a food allergy, roughly two in every classroom. That is why teal pumpkin treats matter: for those children, most of a candy haul is off-limits.

Non-candy Halloween treats under 25 cents

5¢ – 15¢ each

Halloween stickers and sticker sheets

Why it works: Rolls and sheets of pumpkin, bat and ghost stickers are about the cheapest treat there is, weigh nothing and appeal to toddlers and older kids alike. Large stickers are fine for little ones.

Skip it if: you want something that feels more substantial; pair a sticker with a pencil.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

5¢ – 20¢ each

Temporary tattoos

Why it works: Glitter or glow-in-the-dark Halloween tattoos are a hit with school-age kids and fit flat in a bowl. Choose ones labeled non-toxic and follow the package directions.

Skip it if: you are mostly giving to very young children; stickers are easier.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

10¢ – 25¢ each

Halloween pencils and erasers

Why it works: Themed pencils get used at school the next week, so parents like them as much as kids do. Novelty erasers are popular, but small ones are a choking risk for toddlers.

Skip it if: you expect lots of under-3s; hand out pencils without the small erasers.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

10¢ – 25¢ each

Glow bracelets and glow sticks

Why it works: Kids love wearing them on the walk home, and they make trick-or-treaters easier to see. Poison control experts describe the liquid as low in toxicity, but it can irritate the mouth and eyes, so they are for kids old enough not to chew them.

Skip it if: the child is a toddler or likely to bite things; the plastic tube can crack and pieces are a choking hazard.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

Teal pumpkin treats from 25 to 75 cents

25¢ – 60¢ each

Mini notebooks or notepads

Why it works: Pocket notebooks with a Halloween cover are useful and feel like a proper gift. FARE lists stationery among its suggested non-food options.

Skip it if: your budget is tight and you expect a busy street; they add up quickly.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

25¢ – 60¢ each

Mini bubbles

Why it works: Small bubble bottles are fun for a wide age range and are easy to find in bulk party packs around October.

Skip it if: it is very cold or wet where you live; kids will save them for spring.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

15¢ – 50¢ each

Spider rings, vampire teeth and bouncy balls

Why it works: Classic party-favor toys are cheap and very Halloween. Spider rings and plastic fangs are crowd-pleasers with school-age kids.

Skip it if: you are giving to children under three. Small balls and small parts are exactly what the US Consumer Product Safety Commission keeps out of toys for that age group, so keep these for older kids.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

40¢ – 75¢ each

Mini molding clay or play dough

Why it works: A small tub of dough or clay is a satisfying treat that kids can play with that evening.

Skip it if: you have not checked the label. FARE warns that some brands of moldable clay contain wheat, so choose a wheat-free brand or skip it for teal pumpkin bowls.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

Halloween treats for kids at classroom parties

$1 – $3 each

Mini puzzles, card games or activity pads

Why it works: A small jigsaw, a pocket card game or a Halloween coloring pad works as a party favor and keeps kids busy during the class party itself. Teachers often prefer these to food because they avoid allergy checks.

Skip it if: the class has a strict no-favor policy; ask the teacher first.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

$1 – $3 each

Crayon packs and small coloring books

Why it works: Pair a four-crayon pack with a Halloween coloring booklet for younger grades. It is safe for allergy-aware rooms and costs little in bulk.

Skip it if: you are buying for older kids; a fun pen or bookmark suits them better.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

$2 – $4 each

Paperback books or bookmarks

Why it works: Inexpensive Halloween paperbacks from bulk book packs or school book clubs make a lasting favor, and bookmarks are a cheaper alternative. For a class gift to the teacher too, see teacher gifts from the class.

Skip it if: the budget is tight; bookmarks or stickers do the job.

Check on AmazonFind on Etsy

Safety rules for non-food treats

  • Small parts and under-3s. US federal rules ban small parts in toys intended for children under three because of the risk of choking, inhaling or swallowing them. Toys with small parts, small balls, marbles or balloons sold for older kids must carry a warning label. On Halloween night you cannot control who takes what, so keep a separate toddler-safe choice, such as large stickers, ready for little ones.
  • Glow sticks. Poison centers advise keeping glow sticks and glow jewelry out of the mouth, not cutting them open, supervising children who play with them and throwing away any that crack or leak. If the liquid gets in the eyes, rinse with running water for 15 minutes. In the US, Poison Control advice is free, confidential and available 24 hours a day.
  • Latex. FARE suggests choosing latex-free items, because some children are allergic to latex. That rules out many balloons and some rubber toys.
  • Hidden allergens. Some non-food items contain food ingredients, such as wheat in certain moldable clays. Read labels.
  • Separate bowls. Keep food and non-food treats in different bowls so candy does not touch the teal pumpkin treats.

How to plan and budget your treat bowl

A good mix is two or three cheap staples plus one "special" item. As rough examples at typical bulk prices: stickers and pencils alone come to around 15 to 35 cents per child, so 100 trick-or-treaters cost $15 to $35. Swap in glow bracelets and mini notebooks and you are closer to 40 to 75 cents a child, or $40 to $75 for 100. For a class of 25, a $2 favor bag adds up to about $50, so splitting it among a few parents keeps it easy. Buy a little more than you need; most items keep until next year.

Tip: Ask each child to pick one item from the teal bowl. It is faster at the door, makes the treats feel special, and stretches your supply.

Want to go further than trick-or-treat? Our Halloween gift ideas cover kids, adults and coworkers, and boo basket ideas show how to surprise a neighbor with a themed basket.

Frequently asked questions

What does a teal pumpkin mean on Halloween?

It signals that the house offers non-food treats, so children with food allergies can safely trick-or-treat there. It comes from FARE's Teal Pumpkin Project.

What are good non-candy Halloween treats?

Stickers, temporary tattoos, pencils, glow bracelets, mini notebooks, bubbles and spider rings. Most cost 10 to 60 cents each in bulk.

Can I hand out candy and non-food treats?

Yes. FARE says that is fine, as long as you keep the two in separate bowls.

Are glow sticks safe for trick-or-treaters?

For children old enough not to chew them, yes, with supervision. The liquid can irritate the mouth and eyes, and the plastic tube is a choking hazard for small children. Call Poison Control if a child bites one open.

What non-candy treats are safe for toddlers?

Large stickers and sturdy items too big to fit in a small mouth. Avoid small toys, small balls, balloons and glow sticks for children under three.

Sources

  1. Food Allergy Research & Education (FARE) — Teal Pumpkin Project. foodallergy.org
  2. Food Allergy Research & Education (FARE) — About the Teal Pumpkin Project. foodallergy.org
  3. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission — Small Parts for Toys and Children's Products. cpsc.gov
  4. Poison Control (National Capital Poison Center) — Glow Sticks. poison.org

Image credits. Top image: 020211023 151826 Halloween toys by Silar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Written by

Gift specialist and lead author at GiftLoving. Jimmy has worked in the gift business for more than 13 years, makes handmade gifts himself, and writes about what makes a present feel thoughtful to the person who receives it.