Skip to content

Independent gift guides · researched by real people · updated every season

DIY Valentine's Gifts

How to make a date night jar (with 30+ ideas)

A simple Valentine's or anniversary gift that turns "we should spend more time together" into a plan: a color-coded jar of date ideas.

How to make a date night jar (with 30+ ideas)

Quick answer

A date night jar is a glass jar filled with folded slips or wooden sticks, each naming one date idea. Sort the ideas by color (free, cheap, splurge, stay-home) so you can pick one that fits the week, write 30 to 50 specific ideas you would both actually enjoy, and add a short note explaining the rules. It takes an evening to make and costs about $15 to $30.

  • Time 1.5 – 2 hours
  • Difficulty Easy
  • Cost About $15 – $30
  • Makes One jar with 30 – 50 date ideas

The appeal of a date night jar is not the jar. It removes the "What do you want to do?" back-and-forth that ends so many free evenings on the couch, and it turns a vague promise of "more time together" into something you can draw from on a Tuesday. That makes it a thoughtful Valentine's Day gift for a partner who values time over things.

What you need

  • A clear glass jar with a lid, about 24 – 32 oz (a mason jar or a clip-top storage jar)
  • Jumbo craft sticks (about 6 in long) or cardstock in four colors
  • Four colored markers or paint pens, or washi tape in four colors
  • A fine-tip permanent marker for writing the ideas
  • Paper cutter or scissors and a ruler
  • A tag, ribbon or twine, and a small card for the rules
  • Optional: a small envelope of extras (movie tickets, a coffee gift card, a recipe card) tucked into the jar

Tip: Craft sticks last longer than paper slips and are easier to pull out of a full jar. Paper is better if you want to write longer ideas or add small drawings.

How to make a date night jar

  1. Brainstorm a long list

    Write down 50 to 70 ideas before you make anything, then cut the weakest. Think about what you already enjoy together, things you keep saying you should try, and favorite places from early in the relationship. Specific beats generic: "Order from the Thai place and watch the first movie we saw together" is better than "dinner and a movie."

  2. Sort ideas into four categories

    A simple system is green for free, blue for under about $25, red for a splurge that needs planning, and yellow for stay-home nights. Some people prefer categories by mood (active, cozy, adventurous) or by time needed. Pick one system and stick to it so the colors mean something at a glance.

  3. Color-code the sticks or paper

    Paint or marker the top inch of each craft stick, or wrap it with a strip of washi tape. For paper, cut cardstock into strips about 1 x 4 in. If you paint the sticks, let them dry fully before writing on them so the marker does not smear.

  4. Write one idea per stick

    Use a fine permanent marker and keep each idea short enough to read in one glance. Add a detail that makes it feel personal: a place name, an inside joke, or "your pick of dessert." Leave five or six blank sticks so you can add ideas later.

  5. Write the rules card

    Two or three lines are enough: draw one stick a week (or whenever you have a free evening), no swapping more than once, and whoever draws the stick plans it. Rules are what turn a cute jar into a habit.

  6. Label and decorate the jar

    Add a tag or a simple label ("Date nights," your initials, or the year you started dating). A color key on the lid or tag shows which color means what. Keep decoration light so the colored sticks remain the focus.

  7. Fill and finish

    Stand the sticks colored-end up, or fold the paper slips and drop them in. Tie ribbon or twine around the neck, and tuck the rules card and any extras on top.

Date night jar ideas to get you started

Free

  • Sunset walk somewhere you have never walked together
  • Picnic in the living room with a playlist from the year you met
  • Free museum day, outdoor concert or library event
  • Board game tournament, loser makes breakfast
  • Stargazing with a sky-map app and a blanket

Under about $25

  • Coffee and a used-bookstore browse: pick a book for each other
  • Cook a dish from a country neither of you has visited
  • Thrift-store challenge: find each other an outfit on a small budget
  • Mini-golf, bowling or a matinee

Splurge

  • A cooking, pottery or dance class (see experience gifts for couples for more)
  • Dinner at the restaurant you keep saving for a special occasion
  • A day trip to a nearby town

Stay home

  • Recreate your first date at home
  • Build a blanket fort and watch a childhood favorite movie
  • Write each other a letter, swap, and read them out loud
  • Make a memory jar of your own favorite moments together

How to give it as a gift

Hand it over with the first stick already drawn and planned, so the gift starts working that week. On Valentine's Day, pair it with a handmade Valentine card that explains the idea. For a partner who likes surprises, seal a few "mystery" slips in small envelopes that you plan without telling them where you are going.

The jar also works for anniversaries, as a long-distance gift (mail it with ideas you can do over video call), or as a wedding or engagement gift for friends. In that case, keep the ideas general enough that they suit any couple. If you like the format, a love coupon book uses the same principle with tear-out promises.

Tip: Keep a small pile of blank sticks and a marker next to the jar. When one of you mentions something you would like to try, it goes straight into the jar.

Frequently asked questions

How many ideas should go in a date night jar?

Thirty to fifty is a good range. Fewer than about 20 and you will repeat ideas within a few months; more than 50 and quality usually drops. Leave room to add new ideas.

Should the ideas be a surprise to my partner?

It can go either way. A surprise jar feels more like a gift, but you know your partner's tastes best. Many couples fill some of it together after it is given, which keeps every idea something both people want to do.

What if we draw an idea we cannot do right now?

Allow one redraw, or keep the stick aside for better weather or a bigger budget. Color-coding by cost helps here, since you can pick from the color that fits that week.

What jar works best?

A clear, wide-mouth glass jar of about 24 to 32 oz holds 50 jumbo craft sticks easily and lets the colors show. A lidded jar keeps out dust if it sits on a shelf.

For more handmade ideas for February, browse our DIY Valentine's gifts.

Image credits. Top image: Popsicle-sticks by Debbie Miller, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Written by

Gift specialist and lead author at GiftLoving. Jimmy has worked in the gift business for more than 13 years, makes handmade gifts himself, and writes about what makes a present feel thoughtful to the person who receives it.